OK. I've watched enough of this to weigh in. I'm fairly religious, so all the freaky spiritual stuff is pretty powerful to me. I'd be curious what an atheist and/or agnostic thinks about all the messages of angels and forgiveness and God did it. Because even enjoying it myself I see where some might feel cheated by the plot.
Second observation is that there are plot holes and cheats large enough to drive a truck through on a regular basis, but I tolerate because it is so darn beautiful. The cinematography, the performances, the plot twists, the emotion, the costuming and effects. The music. It's just thrilling to watch.
***
Beyond that, on a more personal note, I suspect it is fucking with me. I've got an 11 year old dog with a bandaged foot, where they removed a second tumor and the foot hasn't been healing. I lost both my parents to cancer. I'm living in a city where I don't have any relatives and precious few friends of the conventional sense. While I'm watching this, I'm also rereading "The Lord of the Rings." The last time I read that was out loud, to my mother while she was dying of cancer. As a product of the Internet and BBS' I'm cautious about revealing spoilers. But one of the things I'd do over if I had a chance is to do a Uncle Columbo in "The Princess Bride" where he tells Fred Savage that Wesley doesn't die (or whatever), because she was hanging on the story...right up until Frodo gets "killed" by Shelob, the giant spider. She lost all interest immediately after that--before I could get to the next chapter where Sam finds out he's still alive, and I wasn't able to ever get her back into it. I wound up finishing the book to my dog, who was 2 at the time. Now she's 11 and feeling her years. I feel a bit bad that I'm not reading it aloud to her, but let's face it, the only way you have time for that is if you're on some kind of FMLA leave and you literally have nothing else to do but sit by someone's bed and read to them.
So yeah, I'm in a weird mental state at the moment. And BSG has at least something to do with it.