OMG, you're a PSH fan too?!
I like just about all of his work, but I'll limit it to movies where he's the lead...
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead - Really dynamic take on Greek tragedy, a different type of roll for Philip.
Synecdoche: New York - This movie's unlike any other, it just came out in limited release like a month and a half ago. Possibly one of my favourites, I'll need to see it when it's out on DVD a few times to decide.
Love Liza's one of my top picks despite the story not really going anywhere.
Aside from MI3, I can't think of Philip having any shit roles. My DVD collection has more PSH than anything else.
OH! There's that priest movie coming out soon with Philip and Meryl Streep.