What's new
Troll Kingdom

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Final Cylon

Dual

Dual

RIP Karl 1991-2014
Who better to figure it out than the denizens of The Mine Field?

So it was a human D'Anna knew (and thus the audience knew) but wasn't in the fleet at the time. This gives us two possibilities: The final Cylon is a character who died earlier in the series, or was on the rebel Basestar at the time.

The Original Hybrid in Razor said that the last Cylon was searching for redemption and would only discover its true identity through suffering or something, which leads me to believe that it isn't a dead character. The obvious choice, being both out of the fleet (though temporarily) and in an obvious search for redemption is Baltar. Add to that D'Anna's deference to him when he went to her and told her to stand down. And his apparent use of Cylon projection.

What do you think, MFielders?
 
Baltar is a good candidate, but I don't know why D'anna wouldn't have told him when she saw him.
 
Because she enjoys the tortured sex she gets from Baltar. Guilt can be quite the aphrodisiac.

Hmmm...I'm still leaning towards Billy, since I'm afraid anyone else would be either too obvious or too vague. Maybe Kat?
 
Ellen Tigh
 
Jake the Dog.
 
Now that would be a twist!
 
Not dead, still in the fleet.
 
ever since the 1st time i saw the end of the original mini-series
i have thought Baltar was a cylon
and nothing i have seen since has shaked my belief in this...
 
Dual said:
Now that would be a twist!
Click to expand...

Every single member of the Final Five (so far) was a key member of the Resistance on New Caprica.

Who else played a vital role in the resistence?

Who was just cunningly brought back so that the veiwers don't forget him?

Jake.

The.

Dog.


It's Jake the dog, folks.
 
It's the cat.
 
It's probably just Starbuck's mother.
 
Did D'Anna really say the fifth was someone she knew? It didn't seem to me she that explicitly stated that.

It's possible it was someone on the basestar, but considering they might know the way to Earth, you'd think she would have told them what they were in the hopes it would trigger some new information in their brain or something.

Another thought is that she doesn't really know everyone in the fleet, so it could just be someone she hasn't met before. Someone on a civilian fleet. Oh, but Aaron Douglas said the final five aren't copies, so if it's someone who died, they wouldn't be resurrected (Ellen tigh was a good choice).
 
She didn't say that, but she said that only four were in the fleet. Unless she has the faces of every single person in the fleet memorised, saying that only four were there indicates that she knows where the fifth was.
 
Or that, having not memorised all those faces, she just doesn't know if the fifth is in the fleet, but doesn't want to let on. I agree, she did seem very sure when she said that the fifth wasn't in the fleet, but we know she picks her words very carefully ("I'm in contact with the four already").

Oh and let's not forget that Moore is supposed to have said that the Fifth isn't in the last supper pic!
 
CAPTAIN KELLY
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top