I liked it, quite a lot actually. (DON'T READ ON BEFORE YOU WATCH WACKY OR YOU'LL BE SPOILED AND THERE'S SOME STUFF YOU REALLY DON'T WANT TO BE SPOILED ON)
So, yeah, I liked the pilot. It was great mix of 2001/Sunshine style "hard" sci-fi and some sort of Big Brother like reality TV show. I liked the technology in the show as it was a nice mix of current day and probable future technology. The fact that they have it set in a centrifuge to give them gravity is WONDERFUL.
There's a lot of characters, all of which are nicely introduced and well defined and acted (even if I can't remember half their names). The psychologist was awesome, as was JIMMY JOHNSON, and Sienna Guillory as that hot botanist lady was hot (she's hot and English).
It's also nice they managed to have a probper gay couple without going "HEY LOOK EVERYONE IT'S A GAY COUPLE ON TV DO YOU SEE HOW PROGRESSIVE WE ARE!!!!! WOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!" like other writes do.
I was a bit iffy at first on the whole virtual reality thing, but I think it was quite nicely exectued, with the CGI being just that little bit fake so it actually looks like virtual reality (and it wasn't just bad CGI, as the CGI of the space ship was awesome). The fact thay they managed to turn a funny cheesy secret agent scene into a really quite diturbing rape scene really played the dangers of this virtual reality stuff well, too.
And then there's (SPOILERY SPOILER) the captain dying. Which totally came out of nowhere. And yeah it was a bit cheesy having him somehow still be in the Civil War program but that's what they can explore in the full series.
That is, if they get a full series. I really hope they do, as there's a lot they could do with it. There was a nice feeling of being contained on the ship with the crew, and I hope that's something they keep by rarely going outside it and not having guest actors except in the virtual programs. BUT the problems are that A) this is an intelligent, interesting show on FOX and we all know how that works out, and B) it got VERY LOW ratings due to it being sandwiched between Farrah dying and MJ dying, which is sad but FOX will just see that as it apparently not being a good show (which I think it could be).
So yeah. Good pilot, hope to see more, Sienna Guillory is hot.