Gambit: Part 1 - Riker, Troi, Crusher and Worf are undercover in an ALIEN BAR looking for someone who matches Picard's description. They get a guy with big ears to talk about pretending Picard got Crusher pregnant. There's a code of criminal silence in the bar but they agree to take big ears off the planet if he tells them where Picard is. The upshot is that Picard was vapourised and Crusher identifies his DNA to conclude that yes, he's 100% dead. That's right, they've killed off Picard offscreen! I guess Patrick Stewart fell out with the producers or something. Riker tells Troi he's angry and will stay angry until he finds out who killed the Captain. Troi gets angry and shouts that he's got a responsibility to the crew. An Admiral gives Riker permission to find out who killed Picard (this scene is pointless, really.) Riker threatens Big Ears for more information. They find a planet with several archaeological sites that the mercenaries who killed Picard travelled to. Data, as First Officer, objects to Captain Riker leading the away mission. There's a phaser fight and Riker is captured. The pirate ship somehow manages to disappear from the Enterprise. Worf gets angry at Data's calm and rational command style (didn't this already happen in a previous episoe?) Riker is questioned by the pirate captain (Baran) who has a torture device attached to Riker, and the rest of his crew. Why would you ever sign up to serve a ship like that? Unless his crew are all meant to be slaves or something. A crewmember speaks up, saying Riker must be killed. It's Picard! He's a space pirate now! Frakes makes a great shocked face.
Picard, going by the name Galen, tells the Captain that Riker is a rogue Starfleet officer and Starfleet won't pay a ransom for him. Picard also quickly arranges a malfunction on the ship so Riker can fix it and win Baran's trust. Data follows a lead to another star system. Picard finally explains to Riker that he was shot by a gun that beams things away (that's pretty cool actually!) when he was supposedly vapourised. He'd been tracking the mercenaries after finding out they'd been raiding archaeological sites. They've been stealing Romulan artifacts and Picard wants to know why. Picard has to beat up Riker when Baran walks in on them. Picard convinces Baran to use Riker to get them into a Federation outpost and steal another artifact (to stop them from killing anyone.) Picard tries to get information out of a Romulan crewmember (played by Robin "Second Saavik" Curtis.) Riker fails to get the outpost to drop its shiels but Picard has a convenient way to lower them anyway by doing something to the phasers. The Enterprise shows up and shoots the pirate ship. But Riker hails the Enterprise and orders them to stop attacking. He uses his personal command codes to drop the Enterprise's shields. His codes have been changed but Data orders the shields lowered anyway, knowing that Riker must be doing it for a reason. Worf objects because he's a dick now. The ship fires on the Enterprise to end part one.
Well, it's a part 1! It certainly moves, I'll give it that. The start with Riker and Troi grieving over Picard is a bit weak, because you know he isn't dead and the scene isn't very convincing anyway. But once Riker gets on the space pirate ship it's a lot of fun. Baran is a good evil space pirate type and Picard and Riker pretending to be dicks to each other is always fun. These type of pulpy space grime episodes aren't exactly what TNG does best, but it's good fun for a first part.
SCORE: 7.5/10
Gambit: Part 2 - The pirate ship does little damage to the Enterprise as Picard has sabotaged its phasers, but Data plays along by having the Enterprise appear to be damaged. Data lets the pirate ship go because he thinks it's what Riker wants (Worf continues to be a dick.) Galen taunts Riker so Riker gets to punch him as payback for earlier. Robin Curtis goes to Picard and says she knows he's up to something. Picard makes a positive match on one of the artifacts. Riker gets to lounge around in Baran's quarters. Is Baran gay for Riker? That'st he subtext I'm picking up! Baran says it'll be time to kill Galen soon and he wants Riker to be the one to do it. Worf says "finally" when Data has the Enterprise go after the pirate ship. Data takes Worf aside and tells him to stop being a dick and a First Officer can't keep making sarcastic comments. It's good seeing Data telling him off and being a tough commander, but it really seems out of character for Worf to act like this after seven years of serving with Data. Picard tries to start a muntiny against Baran. Robin Curtis aks him to tell her his real name, with a phaser pointed at him. He tells her the truth and she reveals she's really T'Paal, a member of the Vulcan security force and she's trying to stop Baran getting the artifacts (which are Vulcan, not Romulan.) She tells him the artifacts are a weapon that Vulcans use to kill people using their telepathic abilities. Vulcan isolationists want it. The Enterprise finds a Klingon ship with a really tall Klingon onboard (he's played by some basketball guy I guess.) Worf points out that the Enterprise is allowed to conduct "health and safety inspections" on ships in Federation space (or something, it's just an excuse to bring the Klingon's ship onboard.)
Baran decides they'll have to board the Enterprise to get the artifact the Klingon had. Data and Troi have an awkward drink with the Klingon (he pours it on the floor.) Picard and Riker and the pirates beam onto the Enterprise and shoot Worf and Crusher. Picard shoots Riker DEAD (according to Troi) and beams away with the artifact. Troi says that Riker is "only stunned" and Data says "I must admit I am experiencing a similar sensation" in a good line! Picard punches Baran when he gets back and says it's time for a new commander. Baran tries to kill Picard but Picard switched the transponder codes in the implants so Baran dies (why didn't Baran remove his implant after he killed the older captain?) Riker finds out from Vulcan security that they have no operative on Baran's ship. Picard begins to grow suspicious of Robin Curtis. When they arrived at Vulcan, Picard orders her to leave one of the artifacts behind. T'Paal outs him as an undercover Starfleet officer. Picard outs HER as a Vulcan isolationist who won't pay them. When they get to Vulcan T'Paal kills two of the pirates with the weapon. It kills them one at a time with a really slow moving energy cloud. It's shit. A phaser is much more useful. T'Paal tries to claims it's more powerful than any normal weapon because it uses the power of the mind. Riker and Worf show up but Picard has worked out that the weapon picks up violent emotions and can't kill them if they don't think violent thoughts. Wow, what a shitty weapon! LOVE WINS. Riker says Picard is dead so he can't give orders, but Data points out Riker is a renegade who can't give orders either. Picard orders Data to take Riker to the brig and he does so as Riker protests!!!!
Yeah, part 1 was much more fun. This one just feels a bit dull and the ending is really stupid with the Vulcan weapon turning out to be useless. There's some funny moments with Data and there's still some fun from seeing Riker and Picard pretending to be evil, but I was really losing interest by the end.
SCORE: 6.5/10