pro wrestling 2023 awards
2024 looks to be more dramatic than ever. Stars such as CM Punk, Jade Cargill and Adam Copeland will continue to make waves in their new homes. WrestleMania 40 looks poised to crystallize long-running storylines. Ric Flair, Sting and Billy Gunn continue to defy Father Time with their presence inside the squared circle.
********
Female wrestler of the year: Rhea Ripley, WWE
There's dominance, and then there's Rhea Ripley. As the women's division's resident final boss, Ripley elevated her game to heights seen by few competitors inside the squared circle. She kicked off her year by going wire-to-wire to win the women's Royal Rumble, then she reached her greatest achievement: taking the WWE SmackDown women's championship (now WWE women's world title) from Charlotte Flair at WrestleMania in what was easily considered one of the best matches of 2023.
Male wrestler of the year: Cody Rhodes, WWE
"So ... what do you guys wanna talk about? Let's talk about how Rhodes began the year by coming off injured reserve, having torn his pectoral muscle off the bone and famously wrestling through the injury against Seth Rollins despite gnarly discolored skin. He declared for the Royal Rumble in January, entered as No. 30 and together with Gunther -- who entered first overall -- put on one of the best "final two" showdowns in the event's history.
Tag Team of the year: FTR, AEW
This was a difficult award to choose in 2023. It seemed like tag team wrestling was somewhat deemphasized in the big promotions, even in AEW which has boasted one of the highest-level tag team divisions seen in modern history. There were some bright spots, like the Usos vs. Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens headlining the first night of WrestleMania. But even those two stellar teams were muted in the back half of the year.
Debut of the year: CM Punk, WWE
The WarGames had ended. Cody Rhodes, Jey Uso, Sami Zayn, Seth Rollins and Randy Orton had thwarted The Judgement Day at Allstate Arena outside of Chicago. Fans had been treated to a huge return to the ring by Orton, who got all his spots in and nary a bump against his opponents. The good guys posed and saluted the crowd as music played. On the broadcast, the cameras were zooming out while promotions for upcoming shows were read. Suddenly, CM Punk's logo was plastered around the building's screens as "Cult of Personality" played. He strode out wearing a white T-shirt in between the WarGames cages. The fans went nuclear. The internet lit up. CM Punk was back in the WWE.
Match of the year: Kenny Omega vs. Will Ospreay, AEW (Forbidden Door and Wrestle Kingom)
This one was a tie and an unprecedented one, at that. Omega and Ospreay had two unbelievable matches in 2023 and each one received the most number of votes for this award. And that seems fitting. It was hard to choose which match was better. The first happened way back on Jan. 4 at Wrestle Kingdom in the Tokyo Dome. It was a symphony of violence, more visceral than any other match the two have had before. Omega and Ospreay are superlative athletes and a bout of pure finesse and physical marvels was within their reach. There was some of that in the first match, but it was mostly a bloody war of attrition. Omega gave Ospreay everything he could handle physically, it seemed, including some very perilous-looking bumps on Ospreay's neck.
Best PPV event of the year: Wrestlemania 39, WWE
This is arguably the hardest award to crown, because the work that AEW, New Japan and Impact perform -- among other top promotions -- is top-notch. Yet, the gold standard is WrestleMania for a reason, so much so that other wrestling promotions cater their programming to revolve around (via the schedule) and near (via proximity) the prestigious event.
Best storyline of the year: The Bloodline 2.0, WWE
Fans are frustrated by the lack of Roman Reigns on WWE programming in the latter part of the year and the Bloodline storyline being in something of a holding pattern. Boy, are wrestling fans fickle. It was just a few months ago when people were touting the Bloodline as one of the greatest storylines in the history of pro wrestling. All those people were right, of course. Over the first few months of the year, the Bloodline was on fire with Sami Zayn turning on Reigns and Cody emerging as a foil for Reigns, the Usos, Solo Sikoa and "The Wiseman" Paul Heyman. Heck, the Bloodline owned WrestleMania. The Usos vs. Zayn and Kevin Owens headlined the first night and Reigns vs. Rhodes headlined the second.