In the Pale Moonlight - Sisko records a personal log, struggling to remember the date, saying that he has to justify to himself everything he's done. We flashback to two weeks ago when Sisko posted the weekly casualty list in the wardroom (he speaks in voiceover through the episode as he continues recording his log.) More and more ships are being destroyed, and the Jem'Hadar have been crossing the Romulan Neutral Zone as an advantage without the Romulans doing anything about it (they have a non-aggression pact with the Dominion.) Sisko decides he has to bring the Romulans into the war. He argues to Dax that it's in the best interest of the Romulans to join the war as the Dominion will eventually threaten them, but Dax takes the role of a Romulan and argues there's no reason yet for the Romulans to join. Sisko knows the Romulans will need evidence that the Dominion are plotting against the Romulans and goes to Garak for help with finding any such evidence. Garak tells Sisko it would mean calling in all his old favours on Cardassia and could be a very bloody, messy business but Sisko wants him to go ahead anyway. Kira wakes Sisko with the news that Betazed has been invaded by the Dominion, obviously making him more determined than ever to bring Romulus into the war, but Garak reports that all his old contacts on Cardassia have ben killed after they tried to find the evidence. Garak has another plan, one he thinks Sisko won't like: forge the evidence. Garak wants to convince the pro-Dominion Senator Vreenak that the Dominion are plotting against Romulus by luring him to the station and playing him a holo-recording on an authentic Cardassia data rod. Garak know a forger (Tolar) who can recreate the recording and Sisko gets him out of a Klingon prison where he's awaiting execution. It's not long before Odo's arrested Tolar for trying to kill Quark after Quark steps in to stop him assaulting a Dabo girl (Quark is a hero!) Sisko has to bribe Quark to get him to drop charges against Tolar, much to Quark's delight. Sisko begins to have doubt about the whole thing, but there's always a new casualty list waiting for him and more and more Federation citizens dying. Garak locks Tolar up in his quartes behind a possibly explossive door. He needs bio-mimetic gel to pay the person who can manufacture the data rod. It can be used for some shady stuff, but Sisko has no choice but to order Bashir to give him some. Bashir guilts him a bit by asking for the order in writing and entering a formal complaint.
Tolar's holo-recording of Damar and Weyoun planning to attack Romulus is very convincing (they even bicker about Dukat during it, thanks to Garak.) Sisko keeps Tolar on the station until his work passes inspection. Vreenak arrives on the staton in secret on his cloaked shuttle. Garak searches his ship (this is important later!) while Sisko talks to him. Worf makes a cameo growling at Garak. Vreenak is a bit of a jerk and instantly calls Sisko the man who started the war the with the Dominion. Sisko tries to argue that it would be in Vreenak's best interests to support Romulus joining the war, but Vreenak needs convincing that the Dominion will turn on them. Vreenak watches the recording and askso to examine the data rod. Sisko sturggles to wait before
Vreenak finally returns his verdict. It's all blown up in Sisko's face, all the lies were for nothing. Vreenak rushes back to Romulus to report the lie but two days later Sisko gets the news that Vreenak's shuttle has been destroyed. It's suspected that the Dominion were responsible. Sisko marches straight into Garak's shop and punches him. Garak planted the bomb while he was supposedly searching the shuttle, knowing that the Tal Shiar will find the remains of the data rod in the shuttle and view the recording. Any imperfections will appear to be a result of the explosion. It's the perfect plan! Oh, and he killed Tolar too. Garak tells Sisko that he came to him because Garak could do the things Sisko's conscience wouldn't allow him to do. Sisko knows Garak is right. The Romulans declare war against the Dominion. Sisko reports in his log that it could turn the whole war in the Federation's favour. He lied, cheated, bribed and is an accessory to murder. The most damning thing of all is that he thinks he can live with it. He CAN live with it...
Computer, delete this entire review.
What's most impressive about this episode is the writing. It all starts with the writing! It's really a perfect script with how well it presents Sisko's dilemma. It might seem to be totally against the spirit of Star Trek (GENE'S VISION) but the script (and Avery Brooks) really sells why Sisko would go to such extreme measures. It's credited to Michael Taylor but Ron Moore did an uncredited rewrite that Taylor admitted saved the episode, so once againt Ron Moore has written one of the all time best episodes of Star Trek and deserves credit for that! So yeah it's just a compelling watch all the way, with the brilliant framing device of Sisko's log and expert use of Garak (it's the most terrifying Garak has ever been, but you still can't help but love the guy.) I guess if you really think it strays too far from what Star Trek is "supposed" to be you might not like it, but to me when it's this good, when it's all this believable, I don't really care. It's not just being dark for the sake of dark as some episodes in later series will be (not naming any names!), it's all for a purpose. It's the story-telling that makes it great, not the fact that a Starfleet Captain is partly responsible for several murders.
(Speaking of Garak, when he appeared in four out of six episodes in the season opening act I was like "we're getting a lot of Garak this season!" Then he didn't appear again until this one and doesn't appear again for the rest of the season. But it's five great Garak appearances and that's better than a dozen mediocre Garak appearances!)
SCORE: 10/10
His Way - Most of the cast are in the holosuite enjoying guest star James Darren playing a hologram of himself...I mean, playing Vic Fontaine. Bashir explains that his friend Felix designed Vic to be self aware: he know he's a hologram, makes jokes about it and says "pally" a lot. He can tell Worf and Dax are married, that O'Brien misses his wife, and that there's something between Odo and Kira. Bashir wants them all to hang out with Vic again the next night but Kira is going to Bajor to see Shakaar (lucky her.) Quark advises Odo to forget about Kira as he's missed his chance with her. But Odo isn't ready to give up yet and wants to get advice on wooing a lady from Vic, so Quark lets him spend hours in the holosuite. Vic tells Odo that Kira thinks of him as a friend but Odo can change her mind if he gives her a reason. Vic tells Odo he's a big sadsack in an ugly uniform so he shapeshifts a tuxedo on. Vic sings again while Odo pretends to play the piano. It goes on way too long. Vic has some holo ladies come over for Odo to hang out with. Odo starts singing in a meeting with Sisko.
Vic has a hologram who looks like Kira show up and sing to Odo (it's an excuse to let Nana Visitor sing.) This again goes on way too long. Also remember that one time Kira got really angry at Quark for trying to make a hologram of her? I guess it's okay now? Odo nearly kisses the holo Kira but stops himself because it's inappropriate and she's nothing like the real Kira. The real Kira returns to the station and prays in the Holosuite for some reason (They have a temple on the station! We've seen it many times!) It's an excuse to allow Vic to come and see her and tell her Odo's trying to change for her. He invits Kira to come to the holosuite for a date with Kira, while telling Odo that it's just a hologram he's programmed to be like Kira (Vic has no ethical subroutine apparently.) They have dinner together and Odo can't tell it's the real Kira which doesn't say much for his detective skills. She's nervous to be on a date with him but he tells her not to let it get in the way of enjoying herself. Vic sings again and they dance, getting closer. Odo finally realises it's really her and runs out. He's had enough of Vic's crap. Kira tells Dax she's had a "moment of clarity" and they kiss on the Promenade in front of everyone. Odo returns to the holosuite to report they're an "item" now and leaves it running so Vic can sing a-fucking-gain.
Remember when a future version of Odo ereased thousands of people from existence to save Kira's life? Or when Odo was having sex with the Female Changeling while he was supposed to be helping the resistance and nearly got them all killed? I guess Kira's over those things! We never get to see her and Odo discuss any of it before they get together. I guess you could say they talked about it all in 'You Are Cordially Invited'. Fine, but where did Kira being romantically attracted to Odo come from? It's never been a thing. Ever! And now just because he's loosened up a bit on the holosuite she realise she's in love with him. I don't buy it and it's a shame because Nana Visitor and Rene Auberjonois actually have great chemistry together. Maybe more as friends, but I could see them possibly getting together if the writers did the work. This episode just skips all that and has Odo learn to be cool to win the girl. It almost reduces Kira to a prize for Odo to win. NOW you could say I'm taking it too seriously. This is a screwball comedy of an episode and it follows the logic of those kind of movies. But the problem is their relationship continues beyond this episode! Odo and Kira are now a thing because of stuff that happened in an episdoe that doesn't feel like a part of DS9. James Darren is likable enough but his constant use of old swinger phrases gets old and I don't watch DS9 to watch people singing. Like ten minutes of the episode is just James Darren or Nana Visitor singing. I don't care how good they are, it's not what I'm watching Star Trek for. I don't like this episode much, sorry.
SCORE: 5.5/10