The parts where they're talking about the implications of nobody dying are really interesting, the parts with the CIA trying to kill Torchwood for reasons that probably won't end up making any sense are boring.
Yup, totally agree with that. When it knuckles down and tackles the scifi concept (almost always scenes that don't have Jack or Gwen) it's really interesting and worthwhile to watch. The rest of the time it's a mess. There were so many things bad about this that I completely lost track of them all.
I don't know what Katya from Neighbours's character is called, so I'll call her Katya.
KATYA wears grey trouser suits, doesn't smile unless it's in an evil way, has such a high level of security that the President probably doesn't know she exists and she continues to walk around trying to kill people when her head's back to front. But she still types "???" at the end of emails to her EVEN MORE SECRET boss, like a 14 year old schoolgirl.
RTD's impression of Americans seems to have come purely from Youtube comments sections. "Hey, we saved your asses in World War 2!" "Whaddya gonna do? Complain to your MP?" "Duurrhhh, I don't know Welsh people exist!" Why didn't Jane Exposition tell him to STFU?
Don't forget gay people exist!*
*Once again, you get the impression that RTD's trying to further the cause of gay rights by reminding everyone that gay people exist. FAIR ENOUGH I SUPPOSE, you might think. But he does it by using every gay cliché in the book. Oh, there's a male flight attendant, he must be gay! He denies it, then eventually admits he did have casual gay sex once. Because all gay people are promiscuous and all flight attendants are gay! Sometimes you'd be mistaken for thinking RTD was a homophobic straight guy.
Jack being poisoned went on for too long. It's the second episode out of 10. We know you're not going to kill him off.
I've had enough of this motherfucking Apollo 13 rip-off on this motherfucking plane. "Everybody listen up! We've got 15 minutes of episode two to fill up and all we have are these random pieces of other scripts! Make something fit!"
If I woke up tomorrow and discovered that myself and everyone else in the world was immortal, I probably wouldn't be fixated on some old paedo.
They already did the Welsh/English joke a bunch of times in the first episode, didn't they? Are they going to do it in every episode? What about black pudding? They could have an idiot who keeps asking for black pudding in an irritating Welsh accent.